24 Best Indian Restaurants in New York To Experience With your Elite Companion

    ELITE MUSE

    June 10, 2024

    Best Restaurants

    New York might not be the first place that comes to mind when your tastebuds are craving the authentic spices of India. However, as a melting pot of cultures and cuisines, it’s no surprise that the rich tastes and aromas for which Indian cuisine is famous can be found here.

    Imagine savoring colorful, aromatic dishes reminiscent of the bustling streets of Mumbai or the serene backwaters of Kerala—all without leaving New York’s grounds. Allow Elite Muse to be your guide on this gustatory journey as you and your elite companion indulge in the exquisite flavors and ambiance that are truly, authentically Indian.

     

    Doaba Deli New York

    1. Doaba Deli

    945 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10025, United States

    Doaba Deli is a hidden gem that captures the essence of authentic Punjabi vegetarian cuisine, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. Tucked away behind grimy, papered-over windows, this unassuming hole-in-the-wall offers an entirely vegetarian menu at unbeatable prices.

    The freshly made parathas and dal, piping hot chai, and completely vegetarian offerings create an ambiance reminiscent of a Punjabi restaurant in Delhi but with a New York twist. For those in the neighborhood or passing through, Doaba Deli is the perfect spot for you and your companion to enjoy a comforting cup of chai and a tasty meal.

    2. Jaz Indian Cuisine

    813 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States

    “Best British Indian finally in America!” perfectly captures the essence of Jaz Indian Cuisine, named after its owner, Jaz Rupall. Born and raised as a second-generation British-Indian in Hertfordshire, England, Jaz brought her longing for home-cooked meals to New York City’s vibrant Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood. Nestled on the corner of 9th Avenue and 54th Street, Jaz Indian Cuisine is a delightful gem offering an authentic and flavorful dining experience.

    Visitors often find themselves pleasantly surprised by the perfect blend of spices and generous serving sizes. The Kheer, a rice pudding infused with cardamom, is a heavenly indulgence not to be missed. Jaz herself tends the bar, adding a warm and welcoming touch to her London charm. Due to its popularity, reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant tends to get crowded. The food at Jaz Indian Cuisine is incredibly tasty, and while it caters to American palates, it still retains a sense of authenticity, leaving diners satisfied and eager to return.

    3. Hyderabadi Zaiqa

    366 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019, United States

    Though unassuming and located in a small basement in the heart of Manhattan, Hyderabadi Zaiqa is always packed with patrons eager to enjoy its fantastic Indian cuisine. Despite its modest appearance, with basic wooden tables and a pixelated map of India on the wall, the restaurant surprises with its kind and attentive service, classy place settings featuring real silverware and beautiful metal dishes, and, of course, its exceptional food.

    Diners rave about the classic Butter Chicken, which boasts the ideal chicken-to-sauce ratio with a small kick of spice. The Malabar Curry, with its great spice level and plump shrimp, is another standout dish. Both pair perfectly with the restaurant’s delicious rice. The biryani and appetizers also receive high praise, contributing to the restaurant’s reputation as one of NY’s top 100 restaurants.

    Hyderabadi Zaiqa can become quite hectic due to its limited seating. However, this is no issue with Elite Muse’s restaurant reservation service, ensuring a seamless dining experience. Many opt for takeout due to the tight space, but whether dining in or taking out, the hype around Hyderabadi Zaiqa is well-deserved.

     

    Angel Indian Restaurant

    4. Angel Indian

    7414 37th Rd, Queens, NY 11372, United States

    Simple but great – Jackson Heights’ Angel Indian Restaurant has a small dining room that is almost bare of decoration yet cozy, with the Punjabi music blasting, setting an energetic vibe to the unassuming and easy-to-miss place.

    Named for Chef Amrit’s young daughter, Angel Indian opened in October 2019 and quickly gained recognition, initially because of Chef Amrit’s previous work at Adda and later on its own merits as an excellent halal vegetarian restaurant. Highlights include the goat biryani, featuring a layer of naan on the side, with white sauce to balance the spice.

    The food is absolutely delicious and authentic, with the right level of spice. Reservations are highly recommended due to the restaurant’s popularity; however, with Elite Muse’s reservation service, securing a table is a breeze.

    5. Baazi

    2588 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, United States

    Previously known as Awadh, named after an ancient Hindu princely state, Baazi brings vibrant regional Indian cuisine to New York’s Upper West Side. Renowned for its excellent North Indian food, Baazi is considered one of the best dining spots in Manhattan Valley. Despite its unassuming “hole in the wall” appearance, the restaurant features charming cultural decor and friendly service, making for a delightful dining experience.

    Baazi offers a delectable Asian fusion menu that impresses with both quality and innovation, challenging the common perception that fancy Indian food is overpriced. The butternut squash kofta is an absolute must-try, offering a perfect balance of crispiness and melt-in-your-mouth texture. The mango cocktail, aptly named Indian Summer, is another standout, tasting exactly like mango nectar—a wish come true for cocktail lovers.

    With its spacious interior and a covered, flower-filled patio for outdoor seating, Baazi provides a welcoming atmosphere for you and your tasteful companion.

    6. Kuttanadan Indian Restaurant

    257-05 Union Tpke, Queens, NY 11004, United States

    Kuttanadan Indian Restaurant has quickly become a favorite spot for those craving authentic South Indian and Kerala cuisine. Regular patrons attest to the exceptional quality of the food, noting its homemade taste and the absence of excessive salt or oiliness. Each dish served here is a true reflection of home-cooked goodness.

    Come with company and enjoy some of the diner’s favorites such as the flavorful beef fry, comforting Avial, aromatic Thoren, refreshing moru curry, flaky Malabar parotta, and even the not-so-traditional chicken tikka masala. Conversations with friendly owners and chefs reveal a genuine passion for their craft and a commitment to delivering dishes that meet the highest standards of authenticity.

     

    Cardamom New York

    7. Cardamom

    43-45 43rd street, Queens Blvd, Sunnyside, NY 11104, United States

    Located in Sunnyside, NY, Cardamom Indian Cuisine stands out as one of the finest Indian restaurants in the area. Renowned for its exceptional cuisine, attentive staff, and lively ambiance. Guests rave about the diverse menu, which includes a variety of naans, lassi, starters like paneer, and a range of delectable seafood dishes.

    Particularly noteworthy are the seafood offerings, inspired by the coastal flavors of Goa, a region renowned for its fishing heritage. From the exquisite Goan Fish to the succulent Tandoori Shrimp, these dishes showcase Cardamom’s expertise in Goan cuisine—a subset of Indian food with Portuguese influences. Blending modern culinary techniques with authentic flavors, Cardamom offers a dining experience that is both innovative and true to its roots. Whether you and your date are seasoned Indian cuisine enthusiasts or are trying it for the first time, Cardamom guarantees an unforgettable gastronomic adventure.

    8. Vatan

    409 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

    Nestled in the bustling streets of New York City, Vatan invites diners to embark on a culinary adventure through the flavors of Gujarat, all within the captivating ambiance of a traditional Indian courtyard. Adorned with a magnificent 20-foot tall banyan tree, intricately hand-painted tables, charming thatched roofs, and other delightful details.

    If you seek an exquisite dining affair to treat your companion to, then the renowned Vatan is perfect, centered around the highly acclaimed authentic prix fixe thali. The all-vegetarian menu served prix fixe and all-you-can-eat, caters to a range of dietary preferences and restrictions, ensuring that every guest leaves satisfied.

    9. Sahib

    104 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

    If you find yourself on or around Lexington Avenue, then Sahib is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Indian cuisine. Discovered by many patrons on Eater’s list of best NYC Indian spots, this small but charming restaurant offers a delightful dining experience. With seating for about 30 guests, Sahib provides a cozy and intimate atmosphere perfect for a relaxed meal.

    The diverse menu at Sahib features exceptional Indian dishes that leave guests satisfied and eager for more. Whether you’re there for lunch or dinner, the delicious food, friendly service, and warm ambiance make Sahib a standout choice for Indian cuisine on Lexington Avenue. Don’t forget to take some leftovers and fresh naan home for later!

     

    Saravanaa Bhavan Restaurant

    10. Saravanaa Bhavan

    Established in 1981 by the beloved Mr. P. Rajagopal, fondly known as Annachi, Saravanaa Bhavan has been delighting diners with the simple joy of good food. Renowned for its vegetarian-friendly, vegan, and gluten-free options, this restaurant is a go-to destination for authentic South Indian cuisine that has earned rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.

    Stepping into Saravanaa Bhavan feels like discovering a hidden gem, with its unpretentious, “hole in the wall” ambiance that often signifies the best places for authentic and delicious food. Highlights from their menu include the perfectly cooked mini-tiffin featuring rava-kesari, sambar, mini sambar idly, and dosa. The Mysore masala dosa, chutney, and sambhar are hailed as some of the best in the city, while the fried idli offers a delightful appetizer experience.

    The authentic filter coffee, not overly strong but a perfect complement to the meal, rounds off the experience beautifully. Despite the crowds, which sometimes affect service speed, the substantial portion sizes and delicious food make the wait worthwhile. With convenient locations on both Amsterdam Avenue and Lexington Avenue, Saravanaa Bhavan promises a truly authentic South Indian culinary experience that shouldn’t be missed.

    11. Usha Foods

    255-03 Hillside Ave., Queens, NY 11004, United States

    Over the past 20 years, Usha Foods has grown exponentially through word of mouth, becoming synonymous with taste, quality, and consistently great service. This popular establishment has become a staple on the avenue, with regular patrons frequently visiting for favorites like puri and chole, halwa, vada, methai, and chai. Notably, their vada pav has been featured in Time Out New York as a top vegetarian spot, and everything from the spicy peanuts to the freshly prepared dishes is served with warmth and friendliness.

    From its humble beginnings as a small snack shop, Usha Foods has expanded into a full-fledged restaurant offering delicious idli sambar and other traditional dishes. The unpretentious ambiance, great value, and home-cooked flavors evoke the comforting tastes of a mother’s kitchen, making it a beloved destination for many. It might just become your next favorite vegetarian spot for a date!

    12. GupShup

    115 E 18th St (Between Park Ave &, Irving Pl, New York, NY 10003, United States

    For those seeking a more refined alternative to hole-in-the-wall Indian eateries, GupShup offers an exceptional fine dining experience. It’s the perfect spot for a Friday brunch without the typical weekend rush, providing a sophisticated atmosphere that’s ideal for a memorable date night.

    GupShup’s offerings extend beyond brunch, with a comprehensive lunch menu featuring delights such as Dahi Sev Puri and the irresistible Crispy Okra & Guacamole. A must-try is the Onion Chili Cheese Kulcha, and for the ultimate culinary experience, don’t miss their most celebrated dish, the Keema Pav.

    Guests rave about GupShup, praising it as the perfect spot to satisfy Indian food cravings. The atmosphere, food, and service combine to create a perfect dining experience. Highlights include the unique jackfruit tacos and the mouth-watering carrot halwa a la mode. With an upbeat vibe and friendly servers, GupShup is a must-visit destination for both Indian food enthusiasts and newcomers alike. While it may be a bit pricier for a casual dinner, it’s perfectly reasonable for a special night out.

     

    Temple Canteen

    13. Temple Canteen

    143-09 Holly Ave, Queens, NY 11355, United States

    Nestled in the basement of a Hindu temple in Flushing, Queens, Temple Canteen is renowned for offering some of the best South Indian food in NYC. This famous vegetarian spot serves a variety of authentic dishes such as uttapams and dosas, attracting patrons from all over the city who travel long distances just to savor its incredible, India-like flavors.

    Open to all, Temple Canteen operates like an affordable takeout restaurant but delivers food of a higher quality than its prices suggest. Established in 1993 with the blessings of Sri Maha Vallabha Ganapati, the canteen initially prepared “naivedyam” (food offerings) for deities. Its authentic South Indian fare, including idli, dosa, Pongal, Upma, sambar, and chutney, quickly became a favorite among devotees. In 1998, due to its growing popularity, the canteen moved to its current spacious location in the community center, where it continues to delight visitors with its traditional flavors. Truly an immersive must-visit destination for anyone seeking genuine South Indian cuisine!

    14. Semma

    60 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

    If you’ve ever traveled far into Southern India, you’ll find it shocking that this Michelin-starred South Indian culinary revolution exists right in New York. Semma delves into heritage Southern Indian cuisine rarely seen outside local homes and neighborhoods. Recognized as one of the 100 best restaurants in New York City in 2024, securing a reservation can be challenging. Worry not, though; Elite Muse’s reservation service can easily handle that for you.

    As the only Indian restaurant in NYC with a Michelin star, Semma stays true to its roots, avoiding Americanized expectations. The staff is ready to guide diners through any unfamiliar territory. Signature dishes include the gunpowder dosa, a rice and lentil crepe filled with potato masala, and the attu kari sukka, a tender lamb dish in a richly spiced curry. Starting with the mulaikattiya thaniyam, a flavorful childhood snack of the chef, sets the tone for a meal full of heart and authenticity.

    Diners leave with full bellies and a newfound appreciation for the rich culinary traditions of South India. Dine here with beautiful company, and Semma promises you an unforgettable experience.

    15. Mithaas

    217 Bethpage Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, United States

    Mithaas, a trailblazing restaurant brand in NJ & NY, redefines the traditional Indian quick meal into a contemporary fast-casual dining experience. Their extensive menu boasts authentic street food flavors alongside North & South Indian delicacies, Indo-Chinese delights, and traditional mithai. With four locations across New York and New Jersey, Mithaas brings the vibrant essence of Indian street cuisine to its patrons.

    Customers order at the counter and receive a number for their order, which is promptly prepared and brought to their table. Despite its fast-food essence, Mithaas offers a superior dining experience, highlighted by its diverse selection of chaat. Each dish, like the sev puri dahi puri, is meticulously crafted, presenting a delightful fusion of flavors and textures. Whether indulging in dosas or savoring street food delights, Mithaas invites you and your companion on an exciting culinary journey through the vibrant streets of India.

     

    Jackson Diner

    16. Jackson Diner

    37-40B 74th Street, Queens, NY 11372, United States

    Jackson Diner has been a cherished spot for Indian cuisine enthusiasts for as long as anyone can recall. Consistency has been the hallmark of Jackson Diner’s culinary journey, with their signature dishes like Chicken Tikka Marsala and Sag Paneer continuing to dazzle taste buds. Despite the relocation just across the street, the flavors remain as delightful as ever. The Chicken Tikka Masala paired with garlic naan is a definite crowd-pleaser. Indeed, a visit to Jackson Heights is incomplete without indulging in the culinary delights offered by Jackson Diner.

    Recommended by many and hailed for its quality, Jackson Diner stands as a testament to exceptional Indian cuisine. Whether it’s the freshness of their samosas, the tenderness of their tandoori chicken, or the richness of their Tikka Masala, each dish is a culinary masterpiece. While the ambiance may be modest, the prompt service and delectable food make it a neighborhood treasure worth visiting time and again.

    17. Masti

    184 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

    Nestled in Williamsburg, Masti presents a cozy dining experience with its unassuming exterior and inviting ambiance. Despite its modest appearance, this medium-sized restaurant boasts ample seating and a relaxed atmosphere that grows on you with each visit. As a BYOB establishment, guests can enjoy their favorite beverages alongside their meal in this single dining room setup.

    At Masti, the menu offers a refreshing twist on classic Indian dishes, drawing patrons in with its unique offerings alongside beloved staples. For those seeking quality Indian fare at reasonable prices, Masti delivers, whether you’re opting for dine-in or takeout. From delectable appetizers like the dahi batata sev puri to satisfying mains like paneer tikka masala and chicken tikka masala, each dish is prepared with care, accompanied by freshly baked naan. With attentive service and tempting lunch specials, Masti is a go-to destination for satisfying Indian food cravings in the neighborhood.

    18. Indika House

    943 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206, United States

    Tucked away near the Myrtle-Broadway stop beneath the elevated JMZ tracks, Indika House offers unexpectedly high-quality Indian cuisine. Highly recommended by many, this eatery lives up to its reputation, offering a phenomenal take-out deal that includes a choice of bread, appetizer, and entree, ensuring no appetite goes unsatisfied.

    Beyond the usual Indian takeout fare, Indika House sets itself apart with an extensive menu featuring robust Indo-Chinese dishes and a tempting selection of chaat. Delight in unique appetizers like the fried eggplant chaat, a flavorful surprise for the taste buds. Their signature curry and Hakka noodles also impress, promising a satisfying dining experience.

    For those passing by, Indika House is a must-stop destination, offering flavorful dishes like chicken tikka masala served hot and packed with flavor. Friendly and efficient service complements the meal, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. While the restaurant space may be on the cozier side, the inviting atmosphere and reasonable prices make it a Brooklyn staple worth revisiting time and again.

    19. Lore

    441 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

    Lore presents a unique fusion of Indian cuisine, salad offerings, and inventive cocktails, all under one roof. The restaurant impresses with dishes that burst with flavors, ensuring a memorable dining experience. From the fermented dosa to the roti ravioli, each dish is sure to be an explosion of Indian flavors in your mouth.

    Reservations are highly recommended at Lore, given its popularity and the exceptional dining experience it offers. Thanks to Elite Muse’s restaurant reservation, securing a table becomes hassle-free for you and your stunning companion. With its impeccable service, delectable cuisine, and inviting ambiance, Lore undoubtedly stands out as one of the premier dining destinations in NYC, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.

     

    Dhamaka

    20. Dhamaka

    119 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, United States

    Dhamaka, a culinary explosion of flavors, offers a taste of the lesser-explored regions of India, curated by chef and partner Chintan Pandya and restaurateur Roni Mazumdar. Nestled in the new Essex Market, Dhamaka presents an array of unapologetically Indian dishes, deviating from the usual fare to showcase rustic classics rarely found elsewhere. From Murgh Kofta, reminiscent of a scotch egg with succulent ground chicken in curry, to the delightful Beguni, crispy fried eggplant bites, each dish promises a culinary adventure for the palate.

    With both indoor and outdoor seating available, Dhamaka provides a vibrant ambiance to savor its provincial Indian cuisine. However, due to its popularity, tables tend to fill up quickly, emphasizing the importance of making reservations in advance to secure an unforgettable dining experience. If you’re seeking an exploration of India’s diverse culinary landscape beyond the familiar, Dhamaka stands as a must-visit destination, inviting diners to embark on a flavorful journey through the lesser-known gems of Indian cuisine.

    21. Adda

    31-31 Thomson Ave, Queens, NY 11101, United States

    Adda, hailed as one of the NY Times’ top 100 eateries, beckons with its roots in Angel Restaurant and promises of authenticity.

    From the Chili Paneer’s tantalizing grill marks to the Pav Bhaji’s nostalgic flavors reminiscent of home-cooked meals, each dish captivates with its boldness and meticulous preparation. Complemented by perennial favorites like the Garlic Naan and the Paneer Curry, Adda’s commitment to genuine Indian cuisine shines through, offering a refreshing departure from Manhattan’s upscale dining scene.

    Established in 2018 by Chef Chintan Pandya and Restaurateur Roni Mazumdar, Adda stands as a sanctuary for those seeking authentic culinary experiences. With a menu steeped in tradition and crafted with house-made spices, Adda invites diners to partake in a journey of flavors that evoke nostalgia and warmth. Gather your spice-loving companion and immerse yourself in the essence of India at Adda, where every bite tells a story of heritage and passion.

    22. Punjabi Grocery and Deli

    114 E 1st St, New York, NY 10009, United States

    Tucked away in a basement-level cab stand, Punjabi Grocery and Deli has been a cherished fixture of the East Village since the early ’90s. Nestled amidst iconic landmarks like St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery and Tompkins Square Park, this unassuming spot offers a taste of Punjab right in the heart of Houston Street.

    Whether it’s the sweet indulgence of gulab jamun or the savory satisfaction of samosa chaat, Punjabi Deli beckons with its array of authentic Punjabi delights. With offerings like chana masala and crunchy fried pakora, all at wallet-friendly prices, it’s a go-to spot for locals seeking a filling meal without breaking the bank. Step into this narrow entrance and be greeted by a diverse crowd savoring roti, daal, and sabji, each dish a testament to the simplicity and authenticity of Punjabi cuisine. Amidst the hustle and bustle, encounter Sardar-Ji, the friendly face behind the counter, ready to serve up flavorful delights with a smile. Whether for a quick takeaway or a cozy meal, Punjabi Grocery and Deli promises a wholesome experience that’s as genuine as it gets.

     

    Dosa Royale

    23. Dosa Royale

    258 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

    Dosa Royale, a cherished gem among Fort Greene locals, stands out as a haven for South Indian cuisine enthusiasts. Renowned for its authentic flavors and generous portions, this restaurant has earned the loyalty of its diverse clientele, who appreciates its genuine taste.

    What sets Dosa Royale apart is its dedication to serving traditional South Indian dishes, with a particular focus on dosas, including less common dishes like Avial and Poriyal. Though best enjoyed fresh at the restaurant, even takeout orders maintain the restaurant’s high standards, making it a reliable choice for flavorful South Indian cuisine. For a standout meal, don’t miss out on the original potato dosa—it’s a true winner!

    24. Dhaba

    108 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

    Dhaba, nestled in the heart of Midtown, NY, offers an exquisite array of authentic Indian cuisine that tantalizes the taste buds with its delicate seasoning and bold flavors. The return of their all-you-can-eat lunch buffet, a rare find, especially on weekends, has garnered excitement among food enthusiasts seeking a diverse culinary experience.

    Step into Dhaba and indulge in their lavish lunch buffet, brimming with a delightful selection of Indian delicacies. Despite the dimly lit ambiance, the flavors shine through, leaving diners impressed with each bite. Highlights include the savory chicken tikka masala, creamy palak paneer, aromatic Rogan josh, and crispy samosas. The attentive service adds to the experience, with the staff readily replenishing the naan baskets, ensuring a satisfying dining experience. With its unbeatable value and authentic flavors, Dhaba’s lunch buffet comes highly recommended for those craving a taste of traditional Indian cuisine in the bustling streets of New York City.

    Explore India’s Authentic Spice-filled Cuisine without Stepping Outside NYC

    In a city as diverse as New York, the culinary journey through authentic Indian cuisine is an adventure waiting to unfold. From the bustling hole-in-the-wall joints to the upscale fine-dining establishments, the rich tapestry of Indian flavors beckons gentlemen and their dinner dates on a spice-filled exploration. With Elite Muse’s restaurant reservation services at your fingertips, discovering the best Indian restaurants in New York becomes a seamless experience.

    Embark on a gastronomic odyssey as you sample the vibrant regional cuisines of India, all within the confines of the city that never sleeps. Whether you prefer hole-in-the-wall joints serving up homestyle comfort food or Michelin-starred establishments offering refined dining experiences, New York City has it all. So why wait? Let Elite Muse guide you through the diverse and flavorful landscape of Indian cuisine right here in the heart of the Big Apple.