20 Best Mexican Restaurants in New York for Elite Companionship Dining

    ELITE MUSE

    March 5, 2024

    Best Restaurants

    Looking for a flavorful Mexican cuisine experience for your date in New York City? If you’re craving a burst of flavor, NYC has just what you need.

    Whether you’re a visiting gentleman in search of top-notch NYC Mexican restaurants or a local eager to explore authentic Mexican flavors, our curated list has something for everyone. These restaurants offer a variety of options when you’re hankering for authentic tacos or perhaps a sip of tequila.

    Elite Muse offers more than just a selection of New York’s finest gastronomic offerings in Mexican cuisine. Alongside our expertise in dating and travel companionship, we provide exclusive restaurant reservation services bespoke to you. Allow us to recommend top-tier establishments where you can savor Mexican delicacies while indulging in the company of our elite companions. Elevate your dining experience with our discreet dinner date service, ensuring memorable moments in the heart of New York City.

    Taqueria Sinaloense

    73850 CA-111, Palm Desert, CA 92260, United States

    Step into Taqueria Sinaloense and you’ll find yourself transported to the vibrant streets of Sinaloa. From the moment you walk in, you’ll be greeted by the tantalizing aroma of sizzling meats and freshly made tortillas. The restaurant is best known for its mouthwatering tacos al pastor, prepared with succulent pork marinated in a blend of spices. 

    Savor these authentic delights with your elite companion, and have some of the most engaging conversations you’ll ever have. Like it here? Tell us and we’ll arrange your reservation, ensuring the perfect blend of good food and great company at Taqueria Sinaloense. With Elite Muse’s curated selection of dates, enjoy the perfect blend of good food and great company in this lively taqueriaX

    Mexican food on the table

    La Morada

    308 Willis Ave, Bronx, NY 10454, USA

    La Morada is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the city, known for its simple purple walls and mouth watering Mexican cuisine. The inviting scent of spices and the cozy glow of candlelight will welcome you. The restaurant is best known for its homemade specialties, including a selection of seven hearty moles and savory tamales. With its intimate atmosphere and attentive service, La Morada promises a dining experience that’s as memorable as it is delicious.

    You and your date can enjoy a romantic dinner date here, surrounded by the restaurant’s warm ambiance. Indulge in a shared platter of enchiladas or sample one of the chef’s special creations, all while sipping on a glass of fine wine.

    a-plate-full-of-nachos-on-a-table

    Cazuela Mexicana

    207 E 117th St, New York, NY 10035, USA

    Renowned for its cazuelas, traditional Mexican stews served in clay pots, Cazuela Mexicana promises a hearty and satisfying dining experience. Guests can expect generous portions of flavorful dishes made with fresh ingredients and authentic recipes.

    At Cazuela Mexicana, you and your elite companion can enjoy a lively evening filled with delicious food and laughter. Share a variety of cazuelas, each bursting with bold flavors and rich textures, while enjoying the vibrant ambiance of the restaurant. Sip on refreshing margaritas or sample one of their specialty cocktails as you toast to the night ahead.

    Taco Mix

    234 E 116th St #1, New York, NY 10029, USA

    It’s a taco-tasting adventure for you and your gorgeous companion at Taco Mix. Taco Mix offers a casual and inviting atmosphere where diners can indulge in some of the best tacos in town. With its laid-back vibe and friendly staff, this eatery is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Known for its wide variety of taco fillings and homemade salsas, Taco Mix ensures a flavorful and satisfying dining experience. Expect generous portions and authentic flavors that will leave your taste buds tingling with delight.

    El Mitote

    208 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA

    El Mitote pays homage to the street food of Guadalajara. Established in 1992, this local eatery embodies the spirit of joyful gatherings and conviviality, as suggested by its name. From savory enchiladas to flavorful tamales, El Mitote is best known for its homemade specialties made with love and care. Expect generous portions and bold spices that capture the essence of Mexican cuisine.

    Parada 47

    526 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

    Parada 47 welcomes diners into a bustling and vibrant atmosphere reminiscent of the lively streets of Mexico City. With its eclectic décor and energetic ambiance, this restaurant sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Known for its innovative take on Mexican street food classics, Parada 47 offers a menu filled with bold flavors and creative twists. 

    Share a variety of small plates and tacos, each bursting with unique ingredients and unexpected flavor combinations. Sip on handcrafted cocktails or indulge in a refreshing agua fresca as you soak in the lively atmosphere of the restaurant.

    Tulcingo Del Valle

    665 10th Ave, New York, NY 10036, USA

    For those seeking the finest Mexican cuisine in New York City, Tulcingo Del Valle stands out as a top contender. Renowned for its commitment to authenticity, the restaurant brings the vibrant flavors of Mexico to the bustling streets of NYC.

    Whether one is a native New Yorker or a visitor to the city, Tulcingo Del Valle guarantees a culinary journey that evokes the spirited ambiance of Mexico’s bustling streets. With its cozy ambiance and traditional décor, diners feel like part of the family as they savor authentic Poblano cuisine crafted from time-honored recipes and fresh ingredients.

    Tulcingo Del Valle invites guests to experience the warmth and hospitality of Puebla, Mexico, right in the heart of the US.

    table full of mexican dishes

    Ruta Oaxaca

    35-03 Broadway, Queens, NY 11106, USA

    For those intrigued by Mexican traditions and cuisine, Ruta Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine offers an ideal destination, transporting diners to the rugged landscapes and vibrant markets of Oaxaca.With its rustic décor and earthy ambiance, this restaurant captures the essence of the region’s rich culinary heritage. Known for its authentic Oaxacan dishes, Ruta Oaxaca offers a menu filled with bold flavors and traditional ingredients. 

    The restaurant boasts an extensive collection of tequila and artisanal mezcal to complement its authentic and traditional dishes. Expect dishes that are as bold and colorful as the culture they represent, showcasing the diversity of Oaxacan cuisine.

    black-ceramic-bowl-with-dish

    Cielito

    33-02 36th Ave, Queens, NY 11106, USA

    NYC’s latest showcase of Sinaloan food is Cielito Astoria, a divey yet elegant cocktail lounge on busy 36th Avenue. Outlined in glowing blue neon, it features a foliage-bedecked bench and decorative motifs including skeletons and red roses. Sinaloan banda music plays from an unseen sound system. Managed by Alex Arias and helmed by Sinaloan chef América Rodriguez, Cielito Astoria boasts the city’s broadest menu of Sinaloan cuisine yet.

    Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying each other’s company, Cielito offers the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience with your GFE date.

    Mariscos El Submarino

    8805 Roosevelt Ave, Queens, NY 11372, USA

    This restaurant captures the spirit of a seaside seafood shack as if you’re visiting the coastal regions of Mexico. Known for its fresh and flavorful seafood dishes, Mariscos El Submarino offers a menu filled with mouthwatering ceviches, seafood cocktails, and grilled specialties. 

    Enjoy a relaxed and casual meal together with your beautiful date, savoring the delicious flavors and soaking in the lively ambiance of the restaurant. Share a variety of seafood dishes, from tangy shrimp cocktails to savory fish tacos, each prepared with the freshest ingredients available. Sip on a refreshing michelada or indulge in a tropical cocktail as you toast to the night ahead.

    Classic mexican dishes

    El Gallo Negro III

    4134 Crescent St, Queens, NY 11101, USA

    Known for its traditional Mexican fare, El Gallo Negro III serves up classic dishes with a modern twist, showcasing the rich flavors and bold spices of Mexican cuisine.

    El Gallo Negro III is the ideal option for those looking to avoid the hustle and bustle of airport dining or for those catching a flight with their esteemed travel companion. With its unbeatable combination of delicious food, strong drinks, and welcoming atmosphere, it’s sure to become your go-to spot whenever you’re traveling through the area.

    La Estancia de la Espiga

    La Estancia de la Espiga

    2-13 102nd St. Corona, NY 11368. USA

    La Estancia de la Espiga transports diners to the rustic charm of a traditional Mexican hacienda. With its warm and welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant offers a cozy retreat from the hustle and bustle of the city. 

    At La Espiga, the culinary team hails from various regions including Oaxaca, Morelos, Estado de México, and Tlaxcala, resulting in an array of exquisite recipes brimming with diversity and flavor. A must-try is Sr. Gonzalez’s exceptional pozole blanco, a sumptuous soup made with pork and hominy, prepared according to his family’s cherished recipe from Guerrero. If you find yourself there on a Thursday, don’t miss the opportunity to savor this delectable dish.

    woman standing in front of a mexican store

    Taqueria Coatzingo

    7605 Roosevelt Ave, Queens, NY 11372, USA

    Find Mexican classics in Taqueria Coatzingo right in the heart of New York. For taco lovers, their generously sized and flavorful options offer a delightful challenge in choosing just one. Accompanied by a side of chopped onions, cilantro, and lime wedges, these tacos are a satisfying treat with or without hot sauce. Soups, like the Mole Verde Res Soup, deliver bold flavors, while entrees promise equally delicious experiences. Exploring the menu with a passionate date who shares your love for Mexican cuisine adds an exciting element to the dining adventure.

    Birria-Landia

    Birria-Landia

    Lower East Side; Queens; Brooklyn; and The Bronx

    The excitement surrounding Birria-Landia is undeniable so much so that the wait stretches to about an hour – which is always worthwhile as the food proves.

    The tacos at Birria-Landia are a true culinary delight, boasting juicy, crispy exteriors and rich, flavorful fillings. The consomé served alongside is simply divine, enhancing the taco experience with its depth of flavor. For an extra burst of taste, dipping the tacos in the consomé is highly recommended—an experience that truly justifies any wait.

    At Elite Muse, however, there’s no need to endure lengthy queues. With our reserved tables, you can bypass the lines, saving valuable time and energy. This means more opportunities to savor every moment of your date at Birria-Landia without the hassle of waiting.

    Casa Enrique

    Casa Enrique

    5-48 49th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101, USA

    Casa Enrique, celebrated for its exquisite Mexican cuisine and prestigious Michelin star rating, has captivated Long Island City since its inception on March 15th, 2012. Rapidly ascending to local prominence, Casa Enrique proudly shares cherished family recipes with its patrons. Notably, it has amassed an additional six Michelin stars over the years, while Chef Cosme’s culinary prowess has earned him a James Beard award nomination in Mexican cuisine.

    For those eager to experience Casa Enrique’s culinary magic, Elite Muse offers the convenience of reserving a table for you and your escort date. Embark on a gastronomic adventure at Casa Enrique and savor the essence of fine dining. Bon appétit!

    wrapped taco

    Los Tacos No. 1

    Chelsea Market; Noho; Times Square; Grand Central; Penn Station; and Tribeca

    Los Tacos No.1 was born from the collaboration of three close friends, originally from Tijuana, Mexico, and Brawley, California, who aimed to bring the authentic Mexican taco experience to the East Coast. Rooted in family recipes and crafted from fresh, simple, and flavorful ingredients, every taco from Los Tacos No.1 embodies true Mexican culture and taste.

    At Los Tacos No.1, you and your lovely companion can enjoy casual conversations while indulging in flavorful Mexican fare in the heart of NYC. Bond over the rich flavors and vibrant atmosphere as you get to know each other, creating lasting memories amidst the bustling energy of the city.

    Mitica

    222 Franklin St, Brooklyn, NY 11222, USA

    Nestled discreetly in Greenpoint, Mitica NYC beckons with an air of mystery. Its unassuming facade may not catch your eye at first, but step inside, and you’ll uncover a culinary gem waiting to be discovered.

    Despite its understated ambiance, Mitica NYC surprises with a menu that’s refined and downright thrilling. Take, for instance, their signature aguachile—the “Negro” variation is a bold concoction from El Submarino. Infused with soy sauce and Sinaloa-imported chiltepín peppers, it boasts a captivating gothic hue and a fiery kick that’s not for the faint of heart or palate.

    Taqueria Ramirez

    94 Franklin St, Brooklyn, NY 11222, USA

    Taqueria Ramirez is a neighborhood favorite that delights diners with its authentic Mexican fare and friendly atmosphere. Located in the heart of the city, this cozy eatery offers a welcoming environment where guests can enjoy delicious food and good company. Known for its mouthwatering tacos and homemade salsas, Taqueria Ramirez serves up a taste of Mexico that keeps locals coming back for more. Expect generous portions and affordable prices that make dining here a true pleasure.

    Experience Taqueria Ramirez as if you’re a local. Share this cult-favorite restaurant with your beautiful date, indulging in the flavors of Mexico while creating cherished memories together.

    Lupe’s East L.A. Kitchen

    110 6th Ave, New York, NY 10013, USA

    Lupe’s offers Mexican cuisine with a California flair, featuring favorites like burritos, enchiladas, and taquitos. While it may not boast extravagant decor or claim the title of the city’s best Mexican food, it remains a budget-friendly option, especially if you have a penchant for taquitos.

    Situated in the southwest corner of Soho, Lupe’s exudes a relaxed diner-like atmosphere, perfect for a casual weeknight dinner meeting. Whether it’s a spontaneous outing or a discreet date for the evening, as arranged by Elite Muse, Lupe’s provides an ideal setting for enjoying delicious food and good company.

    Aldama

    91 S 6th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, USA

    Aldama celebrates the rich diversity spanning from Mexico to Brooklyn, forging connections between their origins in its kitchen. It serves as the prime destination to explore unique facets of Mexico, providing a space for joyous celebrations and cultural appreciation.

    With Elite Muse, not only can you arrange a table at Aldama, but you can also secure a date, ensuring you have someone to share and indulge in authentic Mexican cuisine with.

    Experience the Richness of Mexican Cuisine and Culture in the Heart of NYC

    At Elite Muse, we are dedicated to enhancing your evenings with unforgettable encounters with Mexican cuisine and culture. We understand the power of shared meals in fostering meaningful connections. That’s why our carefully curated guide introduces you to the finest Mexican dining establishments in NYC, offering a spectrum of authentic experiences, from renowned classics to hidden treasures.

    Our commitment to excellence doesn’t stop at recommendations. When you book an elite companion, you gain access to our exclusive concierge services, including our restaurant reservation service. Let us secure coveted tables, ensuring your evening is not only luxurious but also intimately exclusive.

    Contact us today to transform your evening into a celebration of the finest Mexican cuisine, vibrant ambiance, and the captivating company of your elite companion. Elevate your dining experience with Elite Muse – where luxury meets unforgettable moments in the world of Mexican gastronomy.